Salt finding from Cassini hints at ocean within Enceladus
Thu Jun 25, 2009 at 13:18 UTC
For the first time, scientists working on NASA's Cassini mission have detected sodium salts in ice grains of Saturn's outermost ring. Detecting salty ice indicates that Saturn's moon Enceladus, which primarily replenishes the ring with material from discharging jets, could harbor a reservoir of liquid water -- perhaps an ocean -- beneath its surface.
Cassini discovered the water-ice jets in 2005 on Enceladus. These jets expel tiny ice grains and vapor, some of which escape the moon's gravity and form Saturn's outermost ring. Cassini's cosmic dust analyzer has examined the composition of those grains and found salt within them.
"We believe that the salty minerals deep inside Enceladus washed out from rock at the bottom of a liquid layer," said Frank Postberg, Cassini scientist for the cosmic dust analyzer at the Max Planck Institute for Nuclear Physics in Heidelberg, Germany. Postberg is lead author of a study that appears in the June 25 issue of the journal Nature.
Scientists on Cassini's cosmic dust detector team conclude that liquid water must be present because it is the only way to dissolve the significant amounts of minerals that would account for the levels of salt detected. The process of sublimation, the mechanism by which vapor is released directly from solid ice in the crust, cannot account for the presence of salt.
"Potential plume sources on Enceladus are an active area of research with evidence continuing to converge on a possible salt water ocean," said Linda Spilker, Cassini deputy project scientist at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Pasadena, Calif. "Our next opportunity to gather data on Enceladus will come during two flybys in November."
The makeup of the outermost ring grains, determined when thousands of high-speed particle hits were registered by Cassini, provides indirect information about the composition of the plume material and what is inside Enceladus. The outermost ring particles are almost pure water ice, but nearly every time the dust analyzer has checked for the composition, it has found at least some sodium within the particles.
"Our measurements imply that besides table salt, the grains also contain carbonates like soda. Both components are in concentrations that match the predicted composition of an Enceladus ocean," Postberg said. "The carbonates also provide a slightly alkaline pH value. If the liquid source is an ocean, it could provide a suitable environment on Enceladus for the formation of life precursors when coupled with the heat measured near the moon's south pole and the organic compounds found within the plumes."
Cassini scientists infer that the temperature of the ice in the south polar region must be close to its melting point (shown in red). A layer of liquid water (dark blue) might exist between the ice and the silicate core (brown), allowing the ice to deform independent of the rock, providing even more mechanical energy and more flexing of the icy shell for extreme tidal heating. Tidal heating could also cause friction in faults near the surface, leading to pockets of partially melted ice. Credit: NASA/JPL
In model A, salty water boils explosively near the surface of Enceladus when it encounters the vacuum of space. This model can be ruled out, because such explosive activity would spread large amounts of sodium into space where it would have been seen by the Earth-based observers. If this model was correct, then nearly all the ice particles observed by Cassini would be salt-rich, instead of just a fraction of them.
In model B, salty water evaporates more slowly at some depth in a narrow fissure, creating vapor which escapes to the surface to form the plume. This model also seems unlikely because the fissure would rapidly become clogged by salt left behind as water evaporates. The water would also freeze, because not enough heat could reach the water surface up the narrow fissure to replace the heat lost by evaporation.
In model C, the warm ice evaporates directly into vapor to form the plume, in a process called sublimation. The salty particles found in the plume would have been created by liquid water in an earlier epoch and would have been stored in the near-surface layers of Enceladus until the present. These particles would now be incorporated into the plume by the escaping gases. This model cannot be ruled out, but seems unlikely because it may be difficult to dislodge old ice grains from the walls of the fracture.
In model D, the liquid water results from melting of near-surface ice rather than coming from an underlying salty ocean. The water is initially only slightly salty, but its salinity increases as evaporation removes some of the water and leaves the salt behind. Thus, in this model, the salt-rich ice particles seen by Cassini would be derived from initially salt-poor water. This model may be plausible and has not yet been evaluated in detail.
In model E, the water is originally salty, and perhaps comes from a subsurface ocean in contact with an underlying rocky core. The water evaporates slowly into a pressurized chamber, from which water vapor and ice particles, including salty particles from the salt water, escape to the surface along narrow fissures. The large area of the evaporating water surface prevents accumulated salt from clogging the vent and allows enough heat to reach the water surface from below to prevent the water from freezing. This model seems he simplest, and perhaps most likely of the models shown here, but is not the only possibility. Enceladus' plumes may involve a combination of several of these idealized models. Credit: NASA/JPL/SWRI/University of Colorado
The yellow circles show the approximate location of two of the active plumes of ice particles identified by the Cassini cameras. The red rectangles show the region of Damascus Sulcus from which heat radiation was measured by Cassini's Composite Infrared Spectrometer (CIRS) at about the same time as the images were taken. The CIRS measurements indicate temperatures up to at least 170 Kelvin (-103 Centigrade or -154 Fahrenheit) near Damascus Sulcus. This is more than 100 degrees Kelvin (180 degrees Fahrenheit) warmer than the surrounding surface, due to heat escaping from Enceladus' interior along the fractures. However, even warmer temperatures are probable over smaller regions close to the tiger stripes, and temperatures are expected to be warmer still below Enceladus' surface. Therefore, subsurface temperatures may be high enough to melt ice to create liquid water, as is suggested by recent Cassini measurements of the salty composition of ice grains ejected from the tiger stripes. Credit: NASA/JPL/GSFC/SWRI/SSI
However, in another study published in Nature, researchers doing ground-based observations did not see sodium, an important salt component. That team notes that the amount of sodium being expelled from Enceladus is actually less than observed around many other planetary bodies. These scientists were looking for sodium in the plume vapor and could not see it in the expelled ice grains. They argue that if the plume vapor does come from ocean water, the evaporation must happen slowly deep underground, rather than as a violent geyser erupting into space.
"Finding salt in the plume gives evidence for liquid water below the surface," said Sascha Kempf, also a Cassini scientist for the cosmic dust analyzer from the Max Planck Institute for Nuclear Physics. "The lack of detection of sodium vapor in the plume gives hints about what the water reservoir might look like."
Determining the nature and origin of the plume material is a top priority for Cassini during its extended tour, called the Cassini Equinox Mission.
"The original picture of the plumes as violently erupting Yellowstone-like geysers is changing," said Postberg."They seem more like steady jets of vapor and ice fed by a large water reservoir. However, we cannot decide yet if the water is currently 'trapped' within huge pockets in Enceladus' thick ice crust or still connected to a large ocean in contact with the rocky core."
| Source: Jet Propulsion Laboratory | |
 |
More on • Cassini • Enceladus |
